I have had no trouble with mine. a 09 FLHR... You say you are going all the way to the left and wiggle move back n forth while applying pressure to the key .....
Are you sure it is the right key???
I have 2 bikes left now, but lucky my 06 sport R. has normal flat key...
when I still had a dyna(barrel key) it could get me into trouble. taking the wrong key out to get it going.. then I color coded the keys with a soft from on the key ring..
signed....BUBBIE