09' FXDL has one of them HD Bar & Shield Logo Self-Locking Fuel Caps. I am really at witts end with this (EDIT) might be broken and never coming off or stuck some how. Anyone else ever have this problem whats the answer? I keep going back out into the garage doing 15 to 20 minute attempts...I have some time rapped up, almost ready to do the pipe wrench thing. Had a shovelhead way back when had a dent in the tank from my boot cause it would not start (didn't start, foot hurt, felt good at the moment)...trying my best to avoid bring out the (EDIT) of my younger days to solve this one. No dealerships where I live. Oh yes I watched youtube, and followed the steps.... Right Hand Threaded Fuel Caps Insert the key. Hold the gas cap in place with your hand. Rotate the key counterclockwise until it will no longer turn. Return the key to the beginning position. Rotate the gas cap counterclockwise to remove. (EDIT) I've even tried turning with key in it.