The quality of the leather is second to none. Like you said, thick but soft. I bought a jacket from them and so did a friend of mine. They went for around $400.00 but you know when you put it on that it is a quality grade of leather. Also, that they are local here in Ma. so I wanted to patronize a local store and not buy a cheap import.
However, I was disappointed in what they told my buddy when his jacket faded badly and you could see the brown leather underneath the dyed black. They told him to spray it with WD40!! Can you believe that? Mine was beginning to fade so I purchased some Doc Baily's. It darkens as well as treats the leather. I wasn't to keen on my jacket stinking of petroleum fluid! Also, my zipper on my jacket, although quality made with thick brass throughout, comes undone!
What a royal pain that is to have to slip the jacket over my head to get it off!! I'm not a big guy mind you.( my buddy is a big guy and yeah, he had to have his zipper replaced $$ ) I do have a slight gut but nothing outstanding. And besides, she suggested that I buy the size smaller! Glad I didn't listen to her ( the aforementioned WD40 lady) and went ahead and bought the larger size. Also, the front pockets on this jacket are practically useless. The are good for perhaps holding a thin pair of gloves but other than than you'd be hard pressed to even get your hands in them! Seriously.
Another thing about Walter Dyer, 35 years ago I bought a pair of moccasins from them. They told me the soles were guaranteed for the life of the stiching. Well me being the hoarder that I am and hang onto things for a long time, took my moccasins there after all those years and showed them the hole in the soles but the stiching intact. I reminded her of the guarantee that they told me when I bought them. No deal. She said that there were new owners and the guarantee was null & void.
So yeah, Walter Dyer has great leather and I'm sure your vest is just fine but my own experience with them hasn't been that great.
After reading this forum and hearing the great reviews about Foxcreek, who I never heard of, I regretted that I didn't buy from them with the $400. that I spent! I do take strongly into consideration our forum members opinions who, over the years have earned my respect, and then based on that, make a decision.
Again, this is just
my rant on Walter Dyer. I am sure you'll be fine, and I'm
glad that you are satisfied!